On September 23, 1908 — Giants P Christy Mathewson and Cubs P Three Finger Brown battle in the most controversial game ever played. The score is 1 – 1, with two outs in the last of the 9th when Fred Merkle’s failure to touch second after an apparent game-winning hit by Al Bridwell scoring Moose McCormick from third costs the Giants a 2 – 1 win; the ump calls Merkle out and rules the game a tie. Merkle’s ‘boner’ will eventually cost the Giants the flag.


Subscribe to This Day In Baseball

Get our latest Posts in your in box

This Day In Baseball on Patreon

Baseball Reference September 23
National Pastime September 23
Retro Sheet
Hall of Fame
SABR Games Project
Replay The Game