The 1959 Homerun Derby

Filmed in December 1959, “Home Run Derby” was a groundbreaking weekly television series that pitted baseball’s top sluggers against one another in head-to-head battles for long ball supremacy. The show took place at Wrigley Field in Los Angeles (home of the Pacific Coast League’s Angels), chosen because of its near-symmetrical dimensions. Unlike modern derbies, hitters were allowed three outs per inning (any pitch in the strike zone constituted an out); the player with the most homers after nine frames was declared champion. Winners received $2,000, with an additional $500 going to anyone who hit three consecutive big flies (another $500 was awarded for a fourth straight home run; anything beyond that was worth $1,000). Though it sounds like chump change today, remember that in 1960 the average big-league salary was around $17,000 a year.
Though the show was short-lived (it ended with host Mark Scott’s tragic death in July 1960), it was nonetheless chock-full of memorable performances. Among the 19 players to take part were future Hall of Famers Hank Aaron, Ernie Banks, Gil Hodges, Al Kaline, Harmon Killebrew, Mickey Mantle, Eddie Mathews, Willie Mays, Frank Robinson, and Duke Snider. The sluggers to make the most appearances were Aaron (7), Mantle (5), Mays (5), Jackie Jensen (4), and Killebrew (4).
“Hammerin’ Hank” put on a clinic, winning six of seven matchups. Mantle, who hit the most homers (44) during the show’s run, posted a 4-1 record, his lone loss coming against Killebrew (9-8). Mays won three of five showdowns, losing to Hodges (6-3) and Mantle (9-8). Other epic battles included Dick Stuart vs. Wally Post (11-9 in 10 innings), Jensen vs. Banks (14-11), and Mantle vs. Jensen (13-10).
 Follow the links below to view selected episodes:
▪️Mickey Mantle vs. Willie Mays: https://youtu.be/HaxrzW3aSrc
▪️Hank Aaron vs. Ken Boyer: https://youtu.be/-pZ6Lvddhrw
▪️Jackie Jensen vs. Ernie Banks: https://youtu.be/I1oM-cdFwKU
▪️Dick Stuart vs. Wally Post: https://youtu.be/HKLuPCsK83Y
▪️Bob Cerv vs. Frank Robinson: https://youtu.be/R7u415RsUjg

 

Other Resources & Links

Baseball-Reference Box Score